| By Jason A. Churchill | ![]() | By 03-30-2009 |
This is going to be quick, random, and from the hip, but this is what I'd do with the M's from today until the day the season starts. Not beyond, and I'm not going to talk about the Morrow thing. They say he's a reliever, I'll treat him as a reliever for now.| 1. By: Blowgun7 on 03-30-2009 17:30:19 Im down with the bullpen, although i anticipate Morrow will head North, bumping White out... I also think they'll keep Corcoran and Batista at the expense of Kelley and Jakubauskas.. I think we're probably looking at: Batista, Corcoran, Lowe, Morrow, Lugo, Jimenez, Aardsma. Im hoping Kelley can somehow impress enough over these last few days to get on the big club for opening day. As for Clement, wish they'd take his catchers mitt and throw in the trash bin because if he doesn't know how to catch by now to meet their standards, I don't think he ever will.. time to deal him or convert him |
| 2. By: Gustafson on 03-30-2009 17:37:44 Re: Alex White, You say he's the most likely to be ready BEFORE 2011. So you think he gets to the Bigs in 2010 sometime? Wow. That would be great... |
| 3. By: stickball on 03-30-2009 18:10:45 Re: Jakubauskas Haha. I thought you said spring training performances are meaningless. |
| 4. By: marinerdan on 03-30-2009 18:13:27 This seems like the most depressing post since Adam Jones was traded. Morrow's value is 1/10 in the bullpen of what it could be as a starter, we are considering Cedeno as a starting shortstop. But most depressing of all, that Alex White would be the most likely pitcher to help in the rotation before 2011. Its amazing how one office can screw over a ballclub so much with one trade. |
| 5. By: Blowgun7 on 03-30-2009 18:25:22 We could be looking at an outfield right now of Shin Soo Choo, Adam Jones, and Ichiro. Not to mention this Morrow news could be blunted if we had Tillman knocking on the door... furthermore, maybe Morrow doesnt move to the pen if George Sherill is back there providing some stability.. Maybe we dont deal Putz if we had those aforementioned players.. I cant believe how badly Lincoln/Armstrong along with Bill Bavasi screwed this franchise |
| 6. By: Slurve on 03-30-2009 18:31:19 what do you think of the M's signing 3B/C Choi Ji-man from Korea? |
| 7. By: Jason A. Churchill on 03-30-2009 18:42:20 stick, The results are meaningless. I knew it. You had no comprehension of the entire discussion. re: Alex White I said the most likely arm to help in the rotation before 2011, that was a prediction of his ETA. |
| 8. By: Gustafson on 03-30-2009 18:47:37 Right. I was just surprised you thought he'd arrive in the Majors that quickly. |
| 9. By: stickball on 03-30-2009 18:51:55 Haha, no. I used the term performances, not results. |
| 10. By: stickball on 03-30-2009 19:15:28 Keep Jaimie Burke in AAA to mentor Clement on defense. I would put Clement second or third in the Tacoma order to get him more at-bats. Morse is suited for the NL where he can fill-in the pinch hit double switch role. Trade him for a LOOGY, Will Ledezma perhaps. Agreed on Corona. |
| 11. By: Jason A. Churchill on 03-30-2009 19:45:37 performance = results, statistics. The only things that matter in ST are approach, responding positively to instruction, showing improvements from said instruction. Again, this is why Betancourt is being shopped and could lose his job to a player that doesn't have the numbers he has. It's not about performance. The performances/results are incidental. re: Clement If Burke goes to Tacoma, you either have three catchers or you have one less pitcher or only two reserve position players. None of which is happening, unless Clement is THE first baseman or DH and isn't going to catch, which would defeat the mentoring purpose of Burke. |
| 12. By: stickball on 03-30-2009 19:57:53 Moore could start the year in AA. Phillips could start in Tacoma too. Phillips plays 1B too, Burke also. Definition of performance - the execution of an action; something accomplished : deed , feat. I don't see statistics and I didn't say that Jakubauskas should make the Tacoma (or Seattle) team solely due to statistics. |
| 13. By: slick on 03-30-2009 20:03:03 any chance the m's look at signing Lackeyin 2010 if he is healthy, Bedard Batista Washburn come off the books and we are kind of light on righthanders. |
| 14. By: stickball on 03-30-2009 20:03:34 EDIT: Delete the sentences about Phillips. |
| 15. By: rightwingrick on 03-30-2009 22:45:44 OK, let's forget Jakubauskas and his spring training performance, stats, results, or whatever....even if he has been the M's best pitcher all spring. Forget that consistency. How about this: in AA and AAA in 2008, he was 8-1 with a 1.88 ERA and a 1.19 WHIP. OK, NOW factor in his consistently good spring performance COMBINED with his consistently good (very similar numbers) spring. If none of THAT counts, why do we play the game? Jakubauskas has earned his way. IMHO, he should start, Silva should work out his problems in long relief. |
| 16. By: Jason A. Churchill on 03-30-2009 23:10:08 Your mixing apples and oranges, rick. His minor league performances can be quantified,not to mention the fact that W-L and ERA are not good indicators of future potential or present performance. and I never ever once said Jakubauskas hasn't earned anything, and as you see above, I just said he deserves to make the big club, but I based that on the fact that Corcoran sucks, Johnson is hurt and I would release Batista... The one thing he's done is throw strikes, always has, and he's throwing strikes with TWO breaking balls right now. I don't care what his numbers are, he's shown enough stuff to be useful in the pen, especially since he can cover multiple innings. Stick, Why would you send Moore, who is a better catching prospect than Clement, back to AA to stunt his growth? |
| 17. By: huhwhat on 03-30-2009 23:44:52 Jason, Any chance the M's are shopping Clement right now? My pipe dream would be packaging Clement and even Yuni to try and get back a Lars Anderson type. Highly unlikely, but man, it's kind of depressing thinking about how the M's first round draft picks are turning out. |
| 18. By: stickball on 03-31-2009 00:14:33 From what I've read, the difference between AA and AAA pitching isn't as large a jump as the difference between AAA and the big show. Moore still needs work on his defense. I'd expect Moore to spend a couple months in AA and a move to be made, probably a trade of Rob Johnson. |
| 19. By: Edman on 03-31-2009 00:48:59 Why in the world would they trade Rob Johnson? Are you assuming Clement suddenly decides to hit? It makes no sense to trade Johnson. Some of you seem to think that trading is cool. They have no idea if Johnson will adapt. If he shows he can defend his position (which isn't a stretch for one of the minor leagues best defensive catchers) and swing an average or better bat, they'd be foolish. There's no rush to move him. Some seem to think the M's are obligated to make space for some kids in the minors. Frankly, they don't have ANY stellar bats that you'd make that move for. Moore needs at least most of this year at AAA. He has a lot of promise, but he's not an uber prospect, he's just a very nice one. You're putting the cart way before the horse. If anyone's going, it's Clement, IMHO. Wak has already stated defense is important behind the dish. So, for Clement to make it, he HAS to hit major league pitching. He has no choice. I've been reluctant to see him moved to first, but I see little other choice. At best, he's a platoon option, but probably not before August, unless he catches fire. Rob Johnson deserves a chance to prove himself. Clement has been given over a year to show anything. He had a brief hot streak after being a September call up, two seasons ago. That's it. Hardly worth throwing your investment in Johnson away for. I'm as big a fan of Clement as anyone. But, you have to face reality. He's lost all the grace period he's going to get. Now, he has to force someone out. |
| 20. By: bigmook on 03-31-2009 00:59:42 JASON- What the hell are we to make of Mike Wilson's homer thing? Please give me your take on his defense and offense. Thanks. |
| 21. By: SvhoopsStar5 on 03-31-2009 09:27:48 Jason, This might get a little too far into what I'm assuming you mention in the Handbook but if you were to build a starting lineup and rotation out of the Mariners Prospects what would it look like? I'm thinking something along the lines of this: C- Moore DH- Clement 1B- Carp/Raben 2B- Corona (if he stays) SS- Triunfel 3B- Tui/De Jesus/Martinez LF- Saunders CF- Halman RF- Gillies SP- Aumonte SP- Ramirez SP- Cleto SP- Pineda SP- Adcock SU- Kelley CL- Fields Sound reasonable?? |
| 22. By: stickball on 03-31-2009 09:50:54 Trading Clement would be selling low, trading Rob Johnson could be selling high. Moore is the future catcher. Do you keep Rob Johnson to play backup catcher? After Wednesday's game the Mariners should place Delgado on waivers for the purpose of outrighting him to AAA. If he doesn't clear waivers or if he refuses assignment then this opens up a spot on the 40 man roster, which can be filled by Jakubauskas or Kelley. If Delgado clears waivers and accepts the outright then they need to clear a roster spot on the 40 man roster before opening day. |
| 23. By: stickball on 03-31-2009 10:10:55 If anyone's going, it's Clement That's a Bavasi move. Clement's not going to get much at this stage, not the amount you would expect a high first round pick would return. Since you know everything, what is this huge investment in Rob Johnson? |
| 24. By: candasharp on 03-31-2009 11:49:24 Unless high value is obtained in return, I doubt if any of the young catchers are going anywhere. Clement's bat is still valuable to the team, especially if Branyan plops out, and you can't trade him as a cather right now. Johnson is the best defensively of all the catchers and could still have a Dan wilson type of offensive upside. Given Johjima's defensive issues, I can't see Johnson going anywhere. Moore needs to prove himself at AAA before they trade him because if he taps his potential both offensively and defensively, his overall skill set probably gives him the long term edge as the starter (not as high offensively as Clement or defensively as Johnson but a very acceptable blend). I'm sure this issue will be revisited at the trade deadline but it seems pretty moot right now. |
![]() |
| Copyright 2010 Prospect Insider | Created by AQ Central Prospect Insider is optimized for Mozilla Firefox and Google Chrome |